Vacation Rentals

Enjoy a quiet and peaceful vacation in a lovely community along the southern shore of Lake Ontario. Fair Haven, New York offers small town hospitality enjoyed by visitors year after year. Located on the Seaway Trail, between Rochester and Syracuse, Fair Haven, NY has year round seasonal activities for everyone.

Cottage Lodging

  • Full Access to Little Sodus Bay
  • Fully Equipped Kitchen
  • Washer & Dryer
  • Ceiling Fans
  • Electric Heat
  • All Linens and Towels Provided

Good Eats

​Turtle Cove Restaurant:
Situated on the waters of Little Sodus Bay, Offering a full Breakfast, Lunch & Dinner.
4 min, walking

Hardware Café - General Store
Serving breakfast, lunch and gourmet coffees in an historic building in the heart of downtown Fair Haven.
​4 min, driving
​
​​Village Grill
Owned and operated by life-long locals.  Serving classic meals familiar to the Finger Lakes and the Lake Ontario shoreline.
​6min, driving

​The Cottage Inn:
This small cottage restaurant is just off of Rte. 104 in Western NY. The service is friendly and efficient.
17 min, driving

Boating

  • Turtle Cove Marina - 3 min, walking
  • Anchor Marina (Rentals) - 13 min, walking
  • Summertime Rentals Kayaks & More - 4 min, walking

Other Attractions

Colloca Estate Winery:
​Colloca Wines are the perfect accompaniment to your meals or social gathering.
13 min, walking

Fair Haven Beach State Park:
​Located on Lake Ontario, this park has one of the finest public shorefronts in Upstate New York.
8 min, driving

Sterling Renaissance Festival:
Witness dozens of artisans demonstrating their fine craftsmanship and selling their unique wares.
13 min, driving

See our cottages

14496 West Side Drive
​Sterling, New York 13156
​(315) 727-5781